Report From Hannover Fair
Stephan Beirer from GAI Netconsult in Berlin sent in this report from the Hannover Messe, a huge event in Europe.
Last year the IT security topic was a bit more prominent at the fair, with several discussion rounds and IT/SCADA security vendors exhibiting. This year the subject is a bit more hidden. Except for Industrial Defender at the RuggedCom booth I couldn’t find any exhibitor specialized in SCADA security.
But it is obvious that the Industrial Ethernet component vendors are taking the network security topic more serious. Several vendors now offer managed switches with special security options (SSH, SNMPv3, port security and physical port lockdown) and industrial firewalls which fit in their product lines, e.g. Phoenix Contact and Weidmueller. The Phoenix firewall is the well-known Innominate MGuard. Hirschmann has recently dropped the cooperation with Innominate. The VxWorks based successor to the MGuard model will be available this summer, offering basically the same functionality.
Hirschmann is planning to integrate some of the firewall functionality into their switches and routers in the near future so the move form Linux to VxWorks is reasonable. Hirschmann also offers robust 61850-3 compliant switches aimed at the substation market (MACH1000, RSR30), while RuggedCom seems to expand from the substation to manufactring networks.
Moxa also seems to have an industrial firewall module, but I didn’t manage to stop by their booth.
A funny story happened at the booth of a well known industrial control system vendor while I was discussing patching strategies for their Windows based products. The vendor guy argued that their system installations have (deja vu!) “no connection to external networks” so that patching is not that time critical as it would be in more open networks (needless to say they validate the MS patches and this takes several months, so they normally integrate the patches in the scheduled release updates, which IMHO takes a bit too long). We were standing in front of a huge 2×3 meter Eyevis projection screen displaying the vendors control system application in action. Just in the moment I was replying that I really doubt that todays modern control system are still isolated from networks like the business network, another sales guy started to show a prospective customer some brand new product features: starting the Internet Explorer with Google Maps on the control system to locate the geographical position of some assets and accessing the homepage of some instrument vendor to order spare parts directly from the control system asset management application…my dialog partner looked quite stunned ;).
Thanks Stephan
Author: Dale Peterson
Posted: April 23rd, 2008 under Conferences, Firewall / Perimeter.
Comments: 4
Comments
Comment from Jake Brodsky
Time: April 23, 2008, 9:59 pm
Dale, I’d be rolling on the floor laughing if this weren’t so damned serious.
Instead, I’m shaking my head. Clearly the developers and marketeers haven’t heard about the issues of patching and security. Either that, or they don’t see the ROI for investing in patch validation staff.
This is so sad…
Comment from Hans Daniel
Time: April 24, 2008, 11:01 pm
Indeed, this is a proof that the SCADA security issue has lost steam …
I really believe we’ll have to wait for a serious SCADA security accident. The Aurora fictive accident did not help much.
Comment from Ron Southworth
Time: April 27, 2008, 9:29 pm
Thanks Stephen always a font of information!
As far as significant incidents changing people’s minds, we already have more than one public incident to refer to that had the sorts of things “designed” to change behaviour. Criminal charges and prosicution, significant fiscal and human costs, yet people in a position of responsability or authority by choice will not learn from other peoples errors. After the initial shock people go back to doing thaings “as usual”.
“People power” is still a good way to resolve this in the combining of our voices as customers. Vendors will get the message about what you want, eventuially. Those that don’t tend to fade away and those that do, will stay around. It is their choice too.
Comment from stephan beirer
Time: April 28, 2008, 10:27 am
Mr Daniel,
an addition to my little report:
I asked all network component vendors how they judge the security market for industrial networks and the general awareness of their customers. Most of them stated that 50% of their customers ask for security while the other 50% lack any sense for that topic. Unfortunateley the awareness of the first group is restricted to demanding a firewall and simple inline “antivirus” scanning in the firewall. We - and the vendors I talked to - know that firewalls with AV alone won’t help much against most of todays threats..
Write a comment